I was really looking forward to receiving this gel liner and another color I purchased from this website. I have been following Marlena and absolutely love her therefore I felt confident purchasing these products. Unfortunately, I am extremely disappointed. The gel eye liner's I received were completely dry and not usable. Although, these products are not her own line, I think it's important to provide good quality products especially if that is what the company is promoting. Unfortunately, this bad experience has led me to purchase products elsewhere.