*LOTS AND LOTS* of dupes....

[melanie]

I have no idea where all of these came from, I just save and save but, thought I would share with you all...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Bare Escentuals Cupcake Glimpse: Milani Illusion
# Bare Escentuals Queen Tiffany: Milani Java Bean
# Bare Escentuals Socialite glimmer: Milani Clover
# Benefit Lemon-aid: Jane Dream Cream
# Bobbi Brown Pale Pink: Clinique Pillowtalk Smudgesicle
# Cargo Nepal: Milani Flare
# Clinique Bronze Satin Shadow: Covergirl Tapestry Taupe
# Clinique Golden Lynx: Covergirl Glazed Ginger
# Clinique Silver Lining (pink): Jane It's A Girl, ULTA Love
# Clinique Strawberry Fudge (pink): Milani Illusion
# Dior GoldFusion: MAC Gorgeous Gold, L'oreal Enlightened Emerald
# Garden Botanika "Bronze" shadow: Jane Sungloss
# Lancome Un Taxi Mauve: Prestige UVA
# Lancome Riot: Jane Deeply Green
# Lancome Contrast: MAC Nocturnelle
# Lancome Golden Sun: Covergirl Burnished Gold
# Laura Mercier Cognac: Milani Spice
# Laura Mercier Whiskey: Prestige Sandalwood
# Lorac Serenity: NYX Sahara Ultrapearl
# L'Oreal HIP Saucy: Milani Sun Goddess/Milani Desert Sun, Prestige Melba, Milani Java Bean
# MAC Shadesticks: NYX Eyeshadow Wands
# MAC Amber Lights: Milani Sun Goddess, Milani Desert Sun, Prestige Melba, L'Oreal HIP Saucy
# MAC Aquadisiac: Jane Millionare
# MAC Atlas: ULTA Silk
# MAC Bamboo: Wild and Crazy Wild Guava
# MAC Banshee: Milani Spice
# MAC Beautiful Iris: ULTA Iris
# MAC Black Tied: Covergirl Shimmering Onyx, Milani Storm, Jane Clubbing
# MAC Blue Noir: Prestige in Ink
# MAC Brill: Wild & Crazy Bahama Water
# MAC Brule: Milani Almondine
# MAC Camel: Revlon Pro Bamboo
# MAC Coco: NYX Beanie
# MAC Cork: M Professinals Soft Brown Eyeshadow, Covergirl Swiss Chocolate
# MAC Cornflower: Physician's Formula Virtual Eyes Loose Shadow in Eye-Tech
# MAC Coquette: Almay Khaki Eye Gel
# MAC Creme de Violet: ULTA Iris
# MAC Crystal: L'Oreal Beauty Queen On-the-Loose
# MAC D'Bohemia: Wild and Crazy Crazy on You, ULTA Knit
# MAC Dazzleray Pigment: NYC Loose Sparkle Eye Dust in Champagne
# MAC Dark Soul pigment: Jane clubbing
# MAC Deep Truth: Loreal On the Loose in Night Fever
# MAC Dementhe: Milani Clover
# MAC Electra: Jane Hi Ho Silver
# MAC Electric Eel: Milani Atlantis
# MAC Embark: Jane Brownie Points, Flirt! Coconutty
# MAC Guacamole: Milani Limbo Lime
# MAC Goldmine: Prestige Golden Retriever
# MAC Gorgeous Gold: L'oreal's Enlightened Emerald Duo, Dior GoldFusion
# MAC Glare: Prestige Golden Sun, ULTA Silk
# MAC Hepcat: Prestige Blossom
# MAC Humid: Milani Clover, WnW Sensual Sage
# MAC Hypnotique: Prestige Saturn
# MAC Jest: Milani Peachy Peach, Maybelline Pink Sands, ULTA Bermuda Sand
# MAC Jewel Blue: Jane Eye Zing in Surfer Girl
# MAC Juxt: Prestige Wasabi, Milani Garden Mist, Jane Rain Forest, ULTA Mist, Jane Sage
# MAC Kicky Blue: L'Oreal Holographic Blue
# MAC Leisure Time: L'Oreal OTL in Flash Light
# MAC Little Madame: Milani Illusion
# MAC Lucky Green: Wild and Crazy Marquis
# MAC Medowland: L'Oreal Wear Infinite in Glistening Sea
# MAC Melody: Jane Millionare
# MAC Metamorph: Rimmel Hope
# MAC Midnight Blue: Jane Blue Jeans, Prestige Horizon
# MAC Mulch: Milani Java Bean, L'oreal HIP in Saucy
# MAC Naked Lunch: Wet n' Wild Fine Wink
# MAC Nocturnelle: Milani Shock, Lancome Contrast
# MAC Nylon: Milani Classic Beige, TooFaced Glamazon
# MAC Paradisco: Flirt! Feeling Hot
# MAC Parfait Amour: Milani Enchantment
# MAC Parrot: ULTA Deep Sea, L'oreal HIP in Showy
# MAC Perverted Pearl: Milani Silver Bullet
# MAC Pink Freeze: Prestige Ballet, Milani Taffy, Cover Girl Pink Chiffon
# MAC Pink Source: Milani Taffy
# MAC Pink Venus: Milani Taffy
# MAC Quarry: Prestige Sandalwood
# MAC Rose: Prestige in Flushed
# MAC Rose Pro: Jame Prom Queen
# MAC Sable: Milani Java Bean
# MAC Satin Taupe: Maybelline Silken Taupe, Rimmel Strength, ULTA Twilight
# MAC Shale: Milani Icy Plum
# MAC Shimmermoss: ULTA Luna
# MAC Silver: Milani in Mercury
# MAC Sketch: Milani Marooned
# MAC Shadowy Lady: Milani Marooned
# MAC Shroom: Jordana Beige, Jane Magic Mushroom, Wet 'n Wild Flirt Shimmer Stick
# MAC Soba: ULTA Toast
# MAC Sprout: Prestige Wasabi, Milani Garden Mist
# MAC Steamy: Milani Clover, ULTA Luna
# MAC Sumptuous Olive: Milani Antique Gold, ULTA Golden Olive
# MAC Sushi Flower: Prestige in Love
# MAC Swish: Prestige Love
# MAC Tilt: YSL Duo ???
# MAC Trax: Prestige Flushed, Flirt! Glamourazzi, Milani Desire
# MAC Unreally Blue: Milani Blue Jeans
# MAC Vanilla: Philosophy Serenity, Wild and Crazy Mist Over Me 3110, Milani Snow Frost
# MAC Vapor: Prestige Chilly
# MAC Vellum: M Professionals Opalescent White, Wild and Crazy Lily Song, Milani Moonlight, Max Factor Spotlight Sparkle
# MAC Vex: Max Factor Mint Matinee
# MAC Wedge: M Professionals Taupe
# MAC Woodwinked: Milani Golden Bronze
# NARS Ashes to Ashes: Maybelline Silken Taupe
# NARS Night Fairy: Prestige Uva, Hard Candy Star
# NARS Tibet: Ben Nye Pearl Shine eyeshadow
# Philosophy Prosperity: Urban Decay Floormat
# Shu ME 945: Caboodles Smooth
# Shu ME945: Majolica Majorca SV821
# Shu P Brown 76: Flirt Oh Please!
# Stila Barefoot Contessa: Prestige Spark, Jane Magic Mushroom
# Stila Go Lightly: Milani Golden Bronze
# Stila Grace: Ulta Plum Smoke
# Stila Heath: Prestige Sandalwood
# Stila Holly Golightly: Milani Golden Bronze, Jane Magical Mushroom
# Stila Jezebel: Garden Botanika "Mimosa"
# Stila Kitten: Wet n Wild Fine Wink, CoverGirl Champagne Eye Enhansers shadow, Sally Girl Silver Lining, ULTA Bermuda Sand
# Stila Pigalle: ULTA Chianti
# Stila Ray: Milani Sun Goddess, Milani Desert Sun, Prestige Melba
# Stila Sun: Prestige Champagne
# Stila Twig: Milani Spice
# Tarte Real McCoy: mark. minx
# Trucco C-Note: Milani Clover
# Too Faced Fantasy Island Duo (Blue): ULTA Luna
# ULTA Love: Jane It's A Girl
# Urban Decay Acid Rain: Prestige Wasabi, Milani Garden Mist
# Urban Decay Asphyxia: MAC Parfait Amour, Milani Enchantment
# Urban Decay Chains: Milani Antique Gold
# Urban Decay Face Case: Fira Face Case, Wet Seal Face Case
# Urban Decay Green Goddess: ULTA Mist
# Urban Decay Grifter: Prestige Uva
# Urban Decay Hotpants: Prestige Love
# Urban Decay Lounge: Physician's Formula Down To Earth
# Urban Decay Midnight Cowboy: Milani Sheer Sand, Sephora Old Rose; Cover Girl Bedazzled Biscotti
# Urban Decay Midnight Cowgirl: Prestige in Glisten
# Urban Decay Mildew: Prestige Iguana
# Urban Decay Oilslick: Covergirl Shimmering Onyx, Milani Storm, Jane Clubbing, Presige Ink
# Urban Decay Polyester Bride: Prestige in Glisten
# Urban Decay Roach: Max Factor Sable
# Urban Decay Roadstripe: Milani Moonlight
# Urban Decay Rust: Prestige in Melba
# Urban Decay Shattered: Naturistics in Azure
# Urban Decay X: Ulta Sunlight, Ulta Sunburst, MAC in Jest
MAC Coppering = NYX Copper
MAC Cranberry = NYX Rust
MAC Amber Lights = NYX Golden
MAC Carbon = NYX Black
MAC Juxt or Golden Olive = NYX Springleaf
MAC Girl Meets Boy = NYX Antique Gold
MAC Swish = NYX Spring Flower
MAC Parrot = NYX Ocean
MAC All That Glitters = NYX Champagne (ES 10)
MAC Naked lunch = NYX Sahara (ES 18)
MAC Vellum = NYX Opal (ES 45)
MAC Rose Blanc = NYX High light (ES07)
Mac Dupes:
C-Thru Lipglass - Milani Secret

Shroom or Nylon Shadow - WnW Cream

Oh Baby Lipglass - Milani Serendipity

Viva Glam V or Lust - Milani Taboo

Vanilla Pigment - L'Oreal Delicate Lace e/s single

Black Tied - Milani Storm

Amber lights - Milani Flare or NYX Golden

Parfait Amour - Milani Shock or Enchantment

Mothbrown - NYX Root Beer

Petticoat - PF Baked Blush in Baked Berry

Gel l/s - NYC Cashmere

Viva Glam V - NYC Mauve Gold

Oyster Girl Lipglass - Bonne Bell Lip Lites in Vanilla Swirl

French Gray - Iced Mocha

Malt - WnW Naked

Well-Dressed blush - L'Oreal Baby Blossom

Amberlights - Milani Sun Goddess

Sumptuous Olive - Milani Antique Gold

Love Nectar l/g - Milani Coral Shimmer

Nymphette l/g - Milani Summer Baby

Hug Me - L'Oreal Chestnut Moisture Extreme l/s

WnW 501B l/s, dupe for MAC Strawberry Blonde

Blue-Brown Pigment - L'Oreal HIP Intrepid

LIP PRODUCTS (lipsticks, glosses, liners, etc)
Chanel Blizzard glossimer = Wet n' Wild Bronzeberry gloss

Chanel Giggle glossimer = Neutragena Chic gloss

Chanel Twinkle glossimer = Prestige Alloy Vinylwear

Chanel Nude liner = Max Factor liner in Nude, Wet n' Wild #666

Clinique Black Honey Almost Lipstick = Maybelline Drippin Honey Wet Shine Lipstick (this is also a dead ringer for the old Bath & Body Works Beautiful By Nature sheer lipstick in Red Grape, discontinued)

Dior Lick of Taffy = Milani Luminous blush applied to lips and topped off with Revlon Super Lustrous lipgloss in Cherry Frost (LE)

Lancome Chai Freeze Juicy Tube = NYC Liquid Lipstick Pen in Kerry

Lancome Simmer Juicy Tube= L’Oreal Strawberry Smoothie and/or Butterscotch Drop Colour Juice

MAC Dainty Cake lipstick = NYC Firefly #306b

MAC High Tea lipstick = Rimmel Airy Fairy, Milani Sheer Lipstick in Amaterro

MAC Lovechild lipglass = Rimmel Snog

MAC Love Nectar lusterglass= Milani Coral Shimmer lipgloss

MAC Lust lipglass= L'Oreal ColuorJuice in Passionfruit Squeeze, Neutrogena Chic gloss (slightly more peach and has slight gold shimmer)

MAC O lipstick = Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick in Copperglow Berry (more cool then O, but still very close), Jordana Bahama Bronze

MAC Oh Baby Lipglass = Milani Serendipity gloss

MAC Prrr lipglass = L'Oreal ColourJuice in Mai Tai (LE)

MAC Plum Liner = Revlon Colorstay Plum liner

MAC Sequin lipstick = Almay Sequin one coat lipstick

MAC Spice Liner = Wet n’ Wild #666 or #712 Liner

MAC VGV (viva glam v [5]) = Milani Sher Lipstick in Pink Chiffon, Neutrogena Moistureshin Tinted Lip Balm in Clean #20

MAC VGV lipglass = Neutragena Dreamy lipgloss or Salley Hansen Diamon Lip Treatment in Royal Romance

Nars Dolce Vita lipstick = Revlon Mauve So Moist moistureshine lipstick (more pink, more shiny)

Nars Orgasm lipgloss = NYC Sungold l/g, Mary Kate and Ashley Truly lipgloss- the best knockoff is to just take Milani Luminous blush and brush on dry lips, cover with clear gloss. Works like a charm and is the closest match.

Nars Pillow Talk lipgloss = Rimmel Vinyl Lip Star in Be A Star

Scott Barnes Flossy Glossy in Meow = Neutrogena Groove Moistureshine

Stila Apricot lip glaze =Prestige Fuzzy Navel Jet Stream Gloss

Stila Jane lipstick = Rimmel birthday suit lipstick (#121, Lasting Finish Lipstick)


***EYE PRODUCTS (shadows, liners, etc)***

Bare Escentuals Cupcake glimpse used wet/foiled= Milani Illusion used dry(cupcake is more gold than pink, illusion is more pink than gold)

Bare Escentuals Queen Tiffany = Milani Java Bean

Bare Escentuals Socialite glimmer = Milani Clover

Benefit Gilded Chubby Liner/Highlighter = Rimmel All Over Color Pencil in Charm (013)

Laura Mercier Cognac = Milani Spice

MAC Bamboo = Wild and Crazy Wild Guava

MAC Brill = Wild & Crazy Bahama Water

MAC Dark Soul pigment = j.a.n.e. clubbing

MAC D'Bohemia = Wild and Crazy Crazy on You (not nearly as shimmery as bohemia)

MAC Embark = j.a.n.e. Brownie Points, Flirt! Coconutty

MAC Gorgeous Gold = L'oreal's Enlightened Emerald Duo- gold shade

MAC Juxt = j.a.n.e. Rain Forest (found in quad)

MAC Lucky Green = Wild and Crazy Marquis

MAC Medowland = L'Oreal Wear Infinite in Glistening Sea (gold sheen instead of silver sheen on medowland)

MAC Metamorph = Rimmel All-Over Pencil in Hope (less yellow, more frosted)

MAC Naked Lunch = Wet n' Wild Fine Wink

MAC Paradisco = Flirt! Feeling Hot

MAC Rosemary & Thyme liner = L'Oreal Forest liner

MAC Satin Taupe = Rimmel All-Over Pencil in Strength (more lavender)

MAC Shroom = Jordana Beige

MAC Trax = Flirt! Glamourazzi

MAC Vellium = Wild and Crazy Lily Song

MAC Vanilla (shadow, *not pigment) = Wild and Crazy Mist Over Me 3110

*****************************************************************************************************
MAC eyeshadows & Milani eyeshadows Versions (MAC on the Left, Milani on the Right)

Amber Lights = Sun Goddess

Black Tied = Storm

Coppering = Flare

Dementhe, Steamy, Humid = Clover

Electric Eel = Atlantis

Guacamole = Limbo Lime

Jest = Peachy Peach

Juxt = Garden Mist (juxt is lighter and yellower)

Little Madame = Illusion

Mulch, Sable = Java Bean

Nylon = Classic Beige

Parfait Amour = Enchantment

Perverted Pearl = Silver Bullet

Pink Freeze = Taffy

Sable = Java

Shale = Icy Plum

Silver Pigment = Mercury

Sketch = Marooned

Sumptuous Olive =Antique Gold

Trax (minus gold) = Desire

Vanilla = Snow Frost

Vellum = Moonlight

Woodwinked = Golden Bronze
*******************************************************************************************************

Shu ME 945 = Caboodles Smooth

Shu P Brown 76 = Flirt Oh Please!

Stila Barefoot Contessa = Prestige Spark

Stila GoLightly = Jane Magical Mushroom eye shadow (discontinued), Milani Golden Bronze

Stila Grace = Ulta Plum Smoke

Stila Jade = Sally Girl China Doll (discontinued)

Stila Kitten = Wet n Wild Fine Wink, CoverGirl Champagne Eye Enhansers shadow, Sally Girl Silver Lining

Stila Sun = Prestige Champagne

Stila Twig = Milani Spice

Urban Decay Acid Rain = Prestige Wasabi

Urban Decay Asphyxia= Milani Enchantment

Urban Decay Midnight Cowboy = Milani Sheer Sand

Urban Decay Mildew = Prestige Iguana

Urban Decay X = Ulta Sunlight

***BLUSH***

Benefit Dandelion = L’Oreal Strawberry Tarte Blush Delice

Chanel Caprice blush = Maybelline Mauve Pulse

MAC Margin = NYX Terra Cotta

Mac Plum Foolery/Nars Sin = L'oreal Color of Hope blush

Nars Deep Throat = Rimmel Apricot Blush

Nars Orgasm = Flirt! Heartthrob, Milani Luminous, Cover Girl Rose Silk Cheeker, Mark. Afterglo, Loreal's LE Front Page Peach

Nars Outlaw Blush = NYC Darling Donner Blush (Holiday '04 Limited Edition)

Nars Sin = Milani Temptation (more deep/brown)

Nars Multiples and Wet n Wild Blush Sticks (Nars on left, WnW on right)

NARS Antibes multiple = WnW (#721) Scandalous

NARS Copacabana multiple = WnW (#724) Flirt

NARS Maldives multiple = WnW Just Peachy

NARS Portofino = WnW (#722) Coy

NARS South Beach multiple = WnW Brazen Babe


***NAIL POLISH***
Chanel Precious = Apt. 5 N-25
Chanel Vamp = Revlon Vixon
Essie Blueberry Crumb = NYC 124A
Essie Wicked = Revlon Vixon
OPI Alpine Snow = Finger Paints Paper Mache
OPI Bubble Bath = Finger Paints Gossamer White or Art Fare Bare
OPI Changing of the Garnet = Revlon Rock Royalty (LE for VMAs 05)
OPI Double Decker Red = Sally Hansen Diamond Honeymoon Red #89
OPI Hawaiian Orchid = Finger Paints All About Art! or Pen and Ink Pink
OPI Im Not Really a Waitress (INRAW)= Revlon Cherry Crush
OPI Jamacia Million = Finger Paintspalette of Platinum
OPI Kyoto Pearl = Finger Paints well Cultured Pearl
OPI Melon of Troy = Wild and Crazy w294 Buffin Bay
OPI Red, Red Rhine= Revlon Raven Red
OPI Tutti Frutti Tonga= Finger Paints Pas-tel Me More
OPI Vampire State Building = Revlon Vixen

[civicbabe627]

HOLY MOLY, that IS A TON!!
Thanks for posting, that's AWESOMEEE!!!!!!!!!

[melanie]

you're welcome!

[Marlena]

Sweet momma!!! That's REALLY helpful!! Nick and I will definitely need to figure out a database of some sort to have all the dupes listed- this is a great start! Thank you!!

[luvmakeupdetroit]

WOWZERS, I DONT THINK I LIKE THE FACT THAT MILANI HAS SO MANY DUPES, SINCE I DONT LIKE MILANI E/S. I DONT LIKE THE STRIP E/S I CANT SEE HOW YOU CAN WORK WITH THEM. QUESTION IS, IS THE COLOR PAYOFF CLOSE TO MAC??? HMMMM.

[cusweets]

Hey that helps so much thanks! I have a lot of Ulta shadows because a friend gave me tons of them. That helps a lot!

[Nick]

Sweet momma!!! That's REALLY helpful!! Nick and I will definitely need to figure out a database of some sort to have all the dupes listed- this is a great start! Thank you!!

Wow -- that is enough to keep us busy for a while

Thanks so much for sharing!

[guinevere626]

wow, what a great list!

[Iris L]

impressive list here

[le pea]

OMG this is an AWESOME list!! THANK YOU!!!!!!

I have some Milani e/s and they do have great color payoff! Now I'm going to get some more, hehe.

And thank you, cause I was looking for a dupe for Nars Orgasm! yay!!

[icosmeticRN]

awsome list!!! I love drugstore makeup and dupes!! this will keep me very busy!!!

[primor2]

does anyone if there is a dupe for albatross and love joy by nars